“It’s complicated.”

Things that we just really really didn’t need in PLL

SHOWER HARVEY 

Ezra’s random non-son Malcolm

SHOWER HARVEY

Making aria cheat and hookup with everyone 

SHOWER HARVEY

Spencer & Caleb hookup 

SHOWER HARVEY

Completely changing Alison just because Sasha put on a bit of weight (she still could’ve worn ‘Ali’ clothes)

SHOWER HARVEY

The 150000 irrelevant characters that were made to look suspicious

SHOWER HARVEY

Killing every second person for no fraking reason except ‘shock’ factor

SHOWER HARVEY

Telling us stuff in interviews instead of the ACTUAL SHOW

SHOWER HARVEY

Predictable & clearly just made for shock factor or to ‘please’ the fans storylines

SHOWER HARVEY

The existence of Ravenswood & a ‘supernatural’ element

SHOWER HARVEY

The police not being able to correctly identify an effing body

SHOWER HARVEY

Making all of the girls hookup with people randomly, like why can’t they be strong independent women? THEY WERE STRONG ENOUGH TO ENDURE -A THEY CAN HANDLE BEING SINGLE.

SHOWER HARVEY

WHY WERE THEY ALWAYS DIGGING AND GETTING CAUGHT AT GRAVES? OBVI YOU’D GET CAUGHT

SHOWER HARVEY

ALLLLLLL of the red herrings, just useless

SHOWER HARVEY

Red herrings AGAIN because they used them so much 

SHOWER HARVEY

The whole Charlotte storyline (MAKING A TRANSGENDER PERSON MENTALLY ILL AND A VILLAIN, ACES) 

SHOWER HARVEY

THE NEVER ENDING PLOT HOLES. NEVER. FUCKING. ENDING. 

SHOWER HARVEY

MORE PLOT HOLES

SHOWER HARVEY

MORE IRRELEVANT RED HERRINGS

SHOWER HARVEY

NOTHING MAKES ANY SENSE

SHOWER HARVEY

m-Aster theory: People lie, but DNA doesn’t.

a man and woman with dark hair are trying to hurt Ali

– Wren & Spencer’s Twin + Melissa protecting Spencer from her

Wren: “I know a doctor that can get you on the pill without your mom knowing” -Alison Dilaurentis

He’s been around since the beginning and recently spotted with a strange acting Spencer (cough, twin).

He has money (a fancy apartment, nice suits etc) which could fund everything A has and does. 

Mental Illness: He mentioned his dad has a mental illness which means it could also be hereditary and could explain his obsession with Ali + the girls

Charlotte: He could’ve been close to Charlotte/Charles through Radley

Radley: He has access to everyone in Radley, he could help get Mona in and out and he also helped Cece (Charles) visit.

Suits: He owns suits which head -A apparently does

Drugs: He has access to drugs and the girls have been drugged many times

Connections: Cece/Charlotte/Charles, Melissa, Mona, Spencer, potentially her twin. 

Doctor: He’s known for “playing with body parts” as A put it

British: the british spelling of Nosey

Hopkins: was written on a box of -As which is a medical institution

OCD: All the -A hoodies and suits are lined up very precisely. Spencer jokes about him having OCD when she goes to his apartment.

Vodka: A drinks vodka as does Wren

Writing: He capitalises his letters and writes in red pen, just like -A (also he forgot the G)

Motels: He stays at motels (earlier in the seasons) and we know A has a thing for seclusion and motels.

Piano: Wren has a piano in his house and A plays the piano

Funeral: he was at Alison’s funeral..WHY?

4×03: song about shoulder bones and hip bones.

Co-owner: and what is this business/apartment that involves him and Melissa?

Drawings: The drawing Wren has looks very similar to the drawing in Ezra’s friends apartment, could they be working together?

Melissa: “Girls fight much dirtier than boys” -Alison Dilaurentis

Melissa says she is trying to protect Spencer..from her twin?

-Hide and Seek: There are several references to hide and seek and that was apparently Melissa and Spencer’s game to play. Melissa could’ve been trying to protect Spencer somehow with this. 

-Queen of Hearts: Melissa admitted to being the queen of hearts (AND THE BLACK SWAN) and she was the one who drugged Aria (who do we know that has access to drugs? WREN)

Toffee: There is that random toffee reference that Mona makes and Melissa is eating (even though aria tells her the flavour she is the one eating it)

Mask: she had a mask just like Alison’s

Wren: she was the one who started out dating wren, she can get drugs from him and there’s this random housing connection..

Cece/Charlotte/Charles: Seems to have fuelled the entire -A game. Connections to the Dilaurentis and Drake families (including Spencer), Lucas, Wren, Ezra (the lair). 

She could’ve been feeling abandoned when along came another sibling (Spencer’s twin) that was similar to her (outcast, mentally ill etc).

TWIN THEORY: 

With Spencer’s drug abuse and gaps in memory, this could be due to a twin drugging her (with help from Wren) or just her type A nature and need for perfection, either way it could’ve been taken advantage of and her twin stepped in to mess things up. 

The initial ‘I think I heard her scream’ Spencer seemed off, and I ALWAYS thought she did it when I first saw it. Now we know Spencer was out of it but it could’ve been her twin. 

Melissa constantly acted sketchy but said it was to protect Spencer. Maybe by being ‘in’ with Wren and -A, she was able to shield her somewhat.

Her breakdown: It could be a hereditary mental illness which her twin suffers from as well. 

The creepy singing to Hanna, that seems like her twin, not her.

When Melissa was ‘caught’ with Cece aka Charles fighting, I believe Spencer was drugged and her twin was running around and that’s when Melissa realised, or something along those lines. 

Wren could’ve been in love with Spencer’s twin and helping Charlotte because they are both Drake’s/siblings.

It’s a stretch but it just seems like there’s a Wren/Melissa/Charles-Charlotte/Spencer’s Twin connection. 

There is A LOT of family drama/connections between the Dilaurentis/Drake/Hastings family so it’s probably linked to that.

A long time ago, like maybe years ago, I remember you said that you had information about the show, (PLL obvs) but then they went in a different direction from what you had heard/saw. Do you think when the show is all over, you could tell us what that info was? If not I understand! I’m just curious :)

Yes yes, I think I actually told everyone a while ago. 

From memory the draft (we’re talking way back in season 4 when i had the last like 4 scripts in the season before they aired) said that Cece had a twin, and that’s who -A/Black Widow was and like the other was redcoat or something and omg Aria was a helper (this is the first time I’ve thought about it in relevance to the new season and omg haha) and I’m trying to remember what else, those were the main points though.